(From Conscious Discipline by Dr. Bailey) Adapted from www.ConsciousDiscipline.com
Give children usable information, instruction and expected behaviors. Name, Verb, Paint Assertive Commands
Notice behavior, non-judgemental descriptions that clearly communicate desired goal.
Send a "just-do-it" nonverbal message with tone and body language, creating a sense of safety Voice of No Doubt
Be aware of intent behind your communication. Assertive communication is about clarity. Your intent is more powerful than your word choice. Making kids obey (aggressive intent) or avoiding conflict (passive intent) is not assertive.
Assertions should be made as requests or commands. Command things that have no wiggle room, that you want the child to do, followed by praise. A request should only be used when there is actually a choice. If you request that your child do something you think they should do, ie "Do you want to take out the trash?" then you are setting them to say that they don't want to and to confuse what is a request and what is a command. When we request and thank the child for doing it, we say to the child to behave well for mommy/daddy - but ideally, 'good' behavior is done as way to participate, show appreciation and care for those we are interacting with - we are family, we are connected, that is why we do helpful things for each other. Do it for mommy/daddy, builds an exterior motivating factor (which might work for you in the short term, but later, when peer groups are valued over parental, you might wish you had done things differently).
Tell and Show Children who Resist
Redirect
Redirecting usually states 'You can't do X but you can do Y' or 'You can't do X here but you can do it there.' When you redirect make sure you connect, join your attention with your child before you redirect. Face-to-face, joint attention, clear boundaries and assistance in connecting with the new object.
Use I-Messages
"I don't like it when you __ " Follow with an assertive command and relate it to safety. "When you ____, I feel ____, because ____." Follow with an assertive command.
I-Message for Verbal and Physical Aggression:
"Victim" First
Kids bump and hit and do things to their friends or brothers or sisters for various reasons, creating aggressor and victim. If we go to the aggressor with admonishments, we give attention to the hurtful behavior and thus show our children how to get our attention (for children, even bad attention can fill the attention quota). To promote helpfulness behavior, let's go to the 'victim' first (*this is true in most situations but there are exceptions, like if a child is hitting or hurting many others, for everyone's safety we go with that particular aggressor first).
Ask "Did you like it?"
(Note the difference between "How did it make you feel?" vs "Did you like it?" Asking how it made you feels give power of victim's feeling to the aggressor. Did you like it asks for a problem-solving answer, not an emotional one. Another problem statement is "use your words" when a child is upset, like adults, when upset we find it difficult to articulate. Try 'did you like it' instead and see if it makes a difference.)
Fault finding and punishment miss the opportunity to teach. With children still in the state of development, teaching missing skills is more valuable.
Teach your child to shift their focus from the problem to the solution by stating their wants, expectations and needs in clear, simple, positive forms (what to do instead of what not to do).
Demonstrate, practice and model the "Just do it" nonverbal body language of assertiveness. To do this we and our children must be able to state our needs without diminishing those of others. We must believe we have a right to them. We must value ourselves. We must first learn it and internalize this in order to teach it. Achieve self-awareness
With aggressive responses, we teach our children to lash out at those who don't follow our rules. When we are passive, we teach them it is ok to infringe and impose on others. Assertiveness is the key to helping them build strong meaningful relationships based on mutual respect. Remember aggression and passivity are both rooted in fear- Aggression linked with the fear of the loss of control and passivity is linked with the fear of hurting or offending other's. Passivity gives power to the unequipped child over the adult. Children often turn this into a game parents don't want to play. To avoid this, use assertive statements with no fear in the intent.
Road Map to Becoming A Bully (Conscious Discipline p271 Here you will see the making of a bully and a chronic victim. Aggressors need to be empowered through positive intent (click on image) and empathy(see below) to then be taught the skills for communicating with others that they are lacking. Chronic victims need to be taught to find their inherent value (positive self-talk) and assert themselves.
(Conscious Discipline p 218) Adapted from www.ConsciousDiscipline.com
Resistance (This should be/This shouldn't be/ What needs to be/ Shouldn't have been) facilitates conflict and reenforces old/bad behavioral patterns. Without questioning our judgments we attack that which contradicts them. We remain stuck perceiving only what we are comfortable with, unable to think critically (not emotionally) and thus unable to change. Our judgements and our thoughts about other's perceptions of ourselves generate fear of mistakes. Without making mistakes, we fear change.
Activity! It is What It Is (aka Acceptance)
To best appreciate this idea, try this 1 minute meditation: Take a deep breath. As you inhale, say to yourself "This moment is as it is." As you exhale, relax and say "Demanding the world go my way creates struggle, not change." For more meditation practices for adults and children. For some, the spiritual aspect of meditation conflicts with their beliefs. Think of meditiation here as a tool of thoughtfulness and reflection. To be able to think logically, we must first accept the emotions we feel, see them for what they are, and then move past them to a state of critical thinking.
For many of us, there were no tools or conversations about emotions. Parents, who knew no more than we did, would try to ignore, dismiss, punish or save us from our emotions, upsets, consequence.
"Don't think about it," "It's not a big deal," etc
or bringing things forgotten to school,
or showing disappointment at our choices
In these behaviors, our parents taught us that negative feelings were bad, needed to be hidden from, escaped. Without tools to deal with negative feelings, what happens to a child who feels the inevitable disappointment?
Emotions are like the weather and we can no more change them as we can the weather - that is why we should teach our children to observe their emotions, be aware of them, and respond wisely. Acceptance of the state, allowing to feel the emotion, and knowing that it will pass is inner strength. Emotions guide our behavior and morality. We are better served understanding them than fearing them or ignoring them.
For some, sitting on the emotion bridge, talking about feelings, retelling the story of the upset, is a way of holding on to the suffering and prevents them from getting over to the landing.
For some, they try to skip over the feeling part all together and go straight to the solution.
Emotions bubble up inside us as sensations, like butterflies or a tightness, unconscious responses to mental strain or delight. If left in the emotional state, we act from the effect of the feeling (emotional state) and not from a place of logic (executive state). That is why we must teach our children to Claim, Name, and Tame!
Activity! How To C-N-T
Activity! Think-Want-Can
(by Daniel Siegel "Mindsight")
Consider teaching your child to use the I think - I want - I can model when talking or writing about difficult feelings.
Activity! Seek to See
(from Project Zero)
Try using this with your children when you don't know what to do as they laugh or point at someone who is different, differently abled, or having some public problem
works like this: The child experiences distress (ie their sister nocked down their tower). They seek out comfort from their attachment figure (ie You). Ideally, the attachment figure provides empathetic comfort, the child feels safe and the relief switches the comfort seeking off. Child returns to play and learn. As children grow, they are better able to regulate and tolerate a wide range of distressful situations.
Activity! Empathy Stages
Learn about the different stages empathy-dev-stages.pdf
If, however, there is no relief the distress grows. This in turn makes them more sensitive to upsets, easier to cause their distress and makes focus and learning harder.
Our goal is to help children develop tolerance to a wide range of emotional distress. That means we must create an inner voice that comforts them and empathizes with them making them and their needs feel seen - this makes the child feel safe. Empathy empowers children to own their feelings and start to regulate.
Empathy can be displayed in different ways, some conscious, some unconscious. For example, there is an automatic, unconscious process happening in our brains, often called "mirror neurons" or motor empathy. It's like having a built-in mirroring system that makes us unconsciously mimic the actions and emotions of others. Try it yourself: Next time you are speaking to someone you can see, even on a video-chat, at a random moment touch your nose with your finger for a few seconds, without commenting on it. The other person most likely will do the same, without noticing that they have done it. Another type of empathy is a more conscious effort. This deliberate attempt to understand another person's perspective and feelings involves putting ourselves in their shoes. Interestingly, both unconscious and conscious empathy can be harnessed to promote cooperation. Take marching and chanting in the army, for example. Done at a specific tempo (around 60-80 beats per minute), it creates a sense of unity through a form of conscious mirroring. We can even leverage these mirroring processes to regulate emotions. By consciously noticing and responding to another person's emotional state through movement, music, and observation, we can help them calm down and deactivate their fight-or-flight response (Behrends, Muller & Dziobek, 2012).
Emotional Empathy , like crying at the sad part of the movie, is mostly an unconscious thing that uses the mirror neurons. We move it into the conscious part of the brain when we state what the child is feeling (ie You seem angry). Cognitive Empathy (aka Theory of Mind), requires imagination and language skills. On the positive side, this skill allows us to understand how a situation might make a child feel. We, as parents, must work towards a non-judgemental acceptance; otherwise, we might get the negative side of cognitive empathy, one where we feel the situation and judge it by our understanding and through our filters. We might gush with sympathy or try to rescue the child, believing they can not handle this situation. Use noticing, describing what the child is doing (plus praise), as opposed to praise or judgment. This is difficult for parents who didn't grow up with this type of behavior, but with some practice - it becomes second nature.
Mature Empathy is the integration of motor, emotional and cognitive. It includes the understanding that we are not responsible for other people's feelings, but we can comprehend and make conscious decisions to be present and loving. Mature empathy has two components.
Immature Empathy
Activity! Empathic Coaching Reflect the inner state back so the child can regulate it enough to adjust their outer behavior. Listen to the person while holding a mental image that the person is not a victim and can handle the situation. Refuse to judge the situation as negative. Imagine the mind as a building with the basement representing the survival state, the ground floor the emotional state and the top floor is the CEO's office, executive state. To get an upset person from the basement to the first floor
Activity! How to D-N-A
Describe what you see in terms of emotions (face and body cues) and physical actions using motor empathy. By judgement free noticing, we create a space for the child to look up at us. When eye contact is made, deep breath and be present in a state of calm. The child needs time to dissipate the emotional intensity, low the perceived urgency of the survival state. To move from the emotional state to the executive state
Name the feeling the child is communicating (You seem __). Use a question tone, so if you are wrong, the child has a chance to correct you. Do not pause here - move quickly to
Acknowledge taking you to the executive state. The reason is that in a moment of pause blame is attributed and emotions are high. Acknowledge the child's desire with positive intent while validating the experience. "You wanted __" and " You were hoping for __" Use a tentative voice so the child can correct you. If you are not sure, ask for more information "You seem __(emotion)__. Something happened?" This is about getting into the problem-solving abilities of the executive state. When we complain and focus on what we don't want, we aren't ready for the problem solving state. When we start to focus on what we want, we are ready to look for a solution.
Learn To Listen
Aggression is not an emotion - it is an expression of emotion. Usually occurs as a result of an excited state. Once a child is excited, some incident or action is perceived as threatening to the child's resources, needs or values. This triggers aggressive behavior in response to the perceived threat.
Socially, children learn that aggression is one way to win, but just as they can learn aggressive solutions, they can learn peacemaking skills. Self regulating emotions is not the same as suppressing emotions - just like expressing is not the same as venting.
These activities help child identify and name, recognize it in others
Activity! Guess the Feeling Write a different emotion on 15 or 20 cards. Child acts out the emotion and you guess what it is. Ask - Can people say one thing with their body/face and another with their words?
Activity! Attach a Pic to the Feeling Label sheets of paper and ask child to find pictures of the emotion in magazines, cut them out and paste them on each sheet. Older kids can brainstorm what each feeling reminds them of. Ask - Have you ever felt this way? What did you do about that feeling?
Activity! Pantomime-Emo Pick an emotion, ie mad. Have child pantomime different actions while feeling that emotion (ie, walk, smile, shake hands, sweep, jump, make a meal etc). Ask - How do people let you know how they feel without words?
Activity! Feel the Beat Ask child to find music that expresses five different emotions (for younger children, bring in five samples and ask them to listen and state what the music makes them feel). For older children, discuss how media manipulates emotions and what tactics they might use - have students keep a record of these types of events for a week, then talk about them. Ask - How does this make you feel? Why would someone what to make you feel a certain way?
Activity! Draw the Emo Draw a picture of hate. Ask - What is the opposite of hate? What kinds of things does hate cause people to do? Can hate change? How? For older kids, request they complete the sentence "Hate is .... " five times. Ask for causes of hate and what behavior is associated with it. Ask older children to write about an experience they had hating someone or something and how they overcame that hate.
Hiding from anger, suppressing or repressing only leads to it coming out later in negative behavior and poor choices. Acknowledge anger as a valid feeling and make sure that child knows they have a choice about how to respond to feelings.
Activity! Grump and Growl Session - Give a space and place to air grievances. For younger kids, you can add a designated angry doll or homemade frustrated toy. Ask for only a few details, like who was involved, what the problem was, and how they tried to resolve the conflict. Unresolved problems can be a teaching moment.
Activity! Bug List - make a list of ten things that bug you. Discuss what you can and cannot do about the problem. What do when someone bugs you? How do you let people know what bugs you? What do you do that bugs others? How would you like them to tell you to stop?
Activity! Comic Bubble Questions - have child imagine a comic bubble above their head. Why am I angry? At whom? How angry am I on a scale of 1 - 10? What am I going to do about it? Train together to answer the questions before acting.
Activity! Imagine the Anger - Have child sit comfortably, eyes closed. Guide the breathing in and out, and ask them to create a fantasy where they meet the person that made them angry. Ask them to imagine the details of the confrontation. Have them imagine how they might respond with aggression. How would the person respond to your aggression? Now ask what would happen if you expressed your anger with words and expectations. How would the person respond now? What kind of positive responses could you think of? Now think of three things you like about the person who angered you.
Activity! Finding the Positive - Talk about what happens to happy thoughts when you get angry. Describe a situation and and ask for negative to positive transition - model: cheating - playing a board game => proud of being honest insulted - being called names on the playground = > feeling grown-up, didn't respond with name calling annoyed - playing ball with inept players => feel mature, didn't get mad - enjoyed the game for what it was.
Self-control takes a long time to learn, depending on child's disposition, developmental stage and maturity. Begin by examining child's own personal power first over others, then over themselves. Children are often not aware that they have power, but that is what self-control is - power over oneself. As they become more proficient in their self-regulation, these practices will help them make their needs known without resorting to aggression.
Activity! Bossy, Bossy - Give child opportunity to be the boss. They get to make anyone in the family or group of friends the following instructions: Jump up and down three times, Recite (children's song), walk around the table, say 'Hi!' to -- , Flap like a chicken, say your name three times, shake hands with -- , rub your tummy and pat your head at the same time. Now change who the boss it, every one gets a turn. After the activity, ask - How did it feel being the boss? How did it feel to be bossed? Could a boss have made people mad at him or her? How? What would happen if someone refused to be bossed?
Activity! Kid Power - for younger children just have a talk, but for older children they can write about it or journal about it. List three ways you make a sibling happy or unhappy. Same for a teacher, parents and friends. Ask - What power do you have over other people? What power do you have over yourself? What power do other people have over you?
Activity! Have to, want to - Talk about things you have to do. With older kids, let them write about it or journal about it. Think of three (to five) things you have to do - why do you have to do them? Rewrite/Restate have to statements to choose to do. Ask how the things you have to do are things that control you, and things you choose to do are things you are controlling. Ask about negative and positive consequence. Ask about internal and external forces. Tie it back to affects on behavior.
Activity! Code of Conduct -
Sublimation sublimation is a healthy coping mechanism. Transforming pain or anger into productive, achievable projects can benefit well-being, relationships, and even physical health.
The Conflict Escalates if:
The Conflict De-escalate if:
Understanding Needs to Assist in Conflict Resolution - awareness of needs helps you define the problem in a more useful way. Think of the needs in a given situation. Consider placing them in of the categories below:
effectiveness - meeting goals, being competent at your job self-esteem - feeling good about yourself authority - being in control of yourself and your situation positive interaction - being liked by others
What needs do you have in this situation? What needs does the child have? How can both sets of needs be met? How can both win?
Activity! Cooling Off
For younger kids learn a silly dance (usually having to do with shaking your hips, then you butt, then your knees) - as you do the silly dance together, notice how the anger dissipates and is replaced by silliness - this is just to get the spark out and give the child, and you, a moment to then reflect and come to a decision about what to do next. For older children, introduce 'cooling down' areas or 'safe spaces'
Activity! Storytelling (k-3)
Tell the story of the conflict (changing the names if you think it is important, but it can have a distracting effect). When the story reaches the point of conflict, stop and ask for possible conflict resolutions. Incorporate one suggestions into the story and end it. Ask if this would a good solution to try next time a similar conflict arises. (For older students, ask them to tell the story about a third person, they the neutral observer). Make sure to flush out the answer with details, otherwise you might get an easy answer to please the caregiver but without thought or intent.
Activity! Bach and Wyden's Fight Fair Method (Grade 2 -6)
Activity! 3 R Strategy (Grade 4-6)
Activity! Snapping Ideas Together (from Harvard Graduate School of Education) When two children, students or groups have two different ideas of how to do something - consider using this technique of 'snapping' the ideas together. This demands listening skills and some flexibility by both parties; a hugely rewarding tool to have once mastered.
Activity! Form A Line - without talking have children (3 or more) to line up from shortest to tallest, tallest to shortest, earliest birthday to latest, oldest to youngest, smallest feet to biggest.
Activity! Bridges - two children face each other hands, palm open, arms stretched out, six inches apart. Have them simultaneously fall forward, catching and supporting each other with their hands, thus forming a bridge. Push each other back to original position. Take a step back and try again.
Activity! Snow Storm - blindfolded partners are led over snow drifts, across frozen streams, around boulders and past other imaginary obstacles. Then switch. Remind - gentle and thoughtful, because you are next!
Activity! Cooperative Musical Chairs - They all win or all lose - no eliminations. Set up like traditional game, but this time the whole group is responsible for all the people, so when the music unexpectedly stops, they have to find a place for everyone to sit (ie laps). Then remove another chair. If anyone falls, the group loses!
Activity! Balloon Freeze - Children (2 or more) bounce balloons on your count - try to reach 50 points. If anyone misses their balloon, everyone freezes until all the balloons hit the floor. They they start over.
Activity! Hats Off Two teams. Place as many hats as their are players in a pile next to each team. The team with all its players wearing hats wins - but all players must have hands clasped behind their back.
Activity! Broomstick Each person in the group holds a stick, about 150 cm, when the leader yells 'now' everyone lets go other stick and grabs their neighbors. When you get comfortable with this game, widen the circle. Yell 'left' or 'right'.
Activity! Empathy Game Grab a bag of things that connect together - brain-flakes, bristle blocks, magnet-tiles, two sets of identical shapes. Blindfold both participates. One is asked to build a simple structure and explain their structure to the partner who then tries to replicate it.
Activity! Kisses - using chocolate kisses or other small treats. Have kids (2 or more) place their arms in arm-wrestling position (but don't call it that). Rules - no talking. You get a chocolate each time the back of your partner's hand touches the desk. Keep track of how many chocolates you get; Stop after 15 seconds. Competition will inevitably ensue. Ask - why did you automatically compete? Did the other person getting a chocolate mean you lost one? What would happen if you had worked together? Are there other situations where we compete without thinking?
Activity!Make it Give children (2 or more) some junk and glue guns. Ask them to make something - a sculpture, an animal, a structure - the only rule is that they must decide as a group what to make. Ask - was it hard to agree on something? Variants - Tinker Toy inventions, puzzles out of cardboard, clay sculptures, murals.
Activity! Turn it Over Two students, preferably a boy and a girl, each get a stick (about the length of their arms). Put a plastic or metal bowl turned over on the ground. Ask them to find a way to turn it over, right side up, without using their hands.
Activity! The Monster Game Grab some paper, pencils, and friends (the more the merrier!). Fold the paper into a paper fan (over under over under again and again until you have several sections), then take turns secretly drawing sections of a monster. Person one starts with the head and neck, hinting at the creature below with the fold. Each player adds their part blindly, drawing the torso, arms, legs, and so on based on the small visible section. Unfold the masterpiece at the end to reveal your collaborative monster creation! Feel free to set a timer for each round or choose a theme for your monstrous menagerie.
Activity! Problem-solving Groups - small groups. Everyone gets to help make a decision and everyone contributes in some way to the final project. Things like:
Activity! Peace Corp - Divide into teams. Team must work together to develop a solution in a limited time. Give each group a description of a different problem. Three minutes to think of a solution. Consequences should be on each card.
Advice from National Center For Youth Issues
Expectations
Build Together
Activity! Worry Dolls
Designate a doll to be the one you tell your worries to. Explain that when you tell a doll a worry, they can help you carry the burden instead of you. Remind child that when the worry grows a little smaller, maybe they can come and talk to you about it.
Activity! Worry Monster
Using a box, like a tissue box, make a monster face with a mouth that worries can be dropped into. Ask child to put the worry monster in an agreed upon place when they want you to read the worries in the monster and to keep it in their room if not. This will create trust between you and allow worries to be shared, when child is ready to do so.
Activity! Where Does It Live?
Accept a child's feelings of stress. Ask for them to point where they feel it the most. This is a good starting point to talk about different kinds of worry they might have.
Activity! Past and Future
The past and future contain many things I cannot control - and great fuel for my worries. But when I make a list of my concerns, I can make a second list for the things I can control. Making this list helps me put things into perspective.
Activity! The Know Better Do Better Motto
The past feels it is filled with mistakes, and they weigh on my mind until I feel burdened, head down, shoulders slumped. But since we know everyone makes mistakes, we can learn from them and decide to do something differently the next time we face a similar problem.
Activity! Worry Chain
Make a paper chain. On one strip write what happened. One the next, what you thought about it. On the next, what you feel about it. Notice that how you think about it influences how you feel about what happened.
Activity! Worry Hat Sometimes we worry about things outside our control and we have a hard time calming down. Some children find a designated 'worry hat' helpful. This can be done with a shirt, dress, socks or any other piece of clothing. Whatever works for your child.
Activity! Liquid Motion Timer
Although it can be a bit pricy, and easily broken, consider buying a liquid motion timer and setting it in a designated 'quiet place.' You can make your own by pouring warm water, glitter glue and glitter into a bottle. Screw the lid on tight and shake. You could also add cooking oil.
Activity! Worry - Unworry
Like the past and future - this is a simple list of worries and subsequent problem solving or thinking of what you can (or cannot) do about each worry. For example, "I am worried about my math test" is the worry and the unworry 'I will spend X amount of time studying for X days before the test.' "I am worried about tornado" and of course I cannot control the weather, but 'I can have safety drills and learn the chances of tornados coming on a particular day.'
Activity! Worry Beans
This is a sensory activity - fill a tub with different sized and colored beans. When you feel stressed, give yourself a few moments to play with the them. Show child the soothing power.
Activity! Mindfulness & Resilience
Activity! Meditation for Kids
Activity! Hook Up (body movement for stress release) (from Coping Skills for Kids) Child will sit on a chair and cross ankles, then extend both arms in front, crossing one wrist over the other, interlacing fingers and drawing clasp hands up toward chest. Child will hold position for 1 minute while breathing slowly, touching the tip of the tongue to the roof of the mouth and relaxing it during exhalation.
Activity! Ninja Walking
when child feels anxious, ask them to walk like a ninja for a few turns around the room. Walking like a ninja means walking very quietly. Focusing on walking and sneaking changes the mood enough to allow to move past the oppressive nature of anxiety.
Activity! Sticks of Possibilities
Have a designated jar in a designated place. Fill it with old popsicle sticks on which you should write strategies to use when you get filled with worries.
Activity! Snowball fight (class activity)
Worry lives within the body, and movement and play can help release some of it, to unhinge the hold it has on us so we can gain perspective to look at the problem in a different or new way - what we can and cannot change about it, what steps we want to take today or in the future. To do this, especially with a group, try writing down the worry or stres on a piece of paper, balling it up and having a snowball fight for 60 seconds. Then pick up a paper, read it and throw it away.